Week 4 Mailbag, Picks and Otherwise
I need a running back to cover a bye week. I could pick up Chester Taylor for a week, or I’ve been proposed a trade of Lee Evans and Matt Forte for T.J. Houshmandzadeh. I don’t know what to do, after this weekend, he’s hard to let go…
Jeff - Fitchburg, MA
Exactly, he’s hard to let go after this weekend. Then, next week you’ll be begging people to take him because he’s stuck on the maddeningly inconsistent Bengals. Carson Palmer hasn’t fully regained his normal capabilities after his injury, and the team is simply a mess of unhappy players, betrayed coaches, inept GMs, frustrated superstars and Halloween costumes for uniforms. Do yourself a favor, and unload T.J. for two guys who will be much more consistent, even though either one of those players may not outscore him by themselves this season. Stop the insanity of paying attention to the Bengals games on Sundays and you’ll sleep much better at night.
You had St. Louis winning the NFC West and Tennessee finishing last in the AFC South. Now that the Rams are 0-3 and the Titans are 3-0, do you want to use this opportunity to defend yourself?
Todd - Falmouth, MA
I’m done defending the Rams, so I’ll explain the Titans. First of all, they have beaten two incompetent teams in Cincinnati and Houston. Secondly, I made that prediction under the assumption that Vince Young would be their quarterback for the entire season. Now, that’s not to say Kerry Collins should have the starting job, or is even a middle-of-the-road quarterback, but he’s not as boneheaded as Young and is good for a few less mistakes per game.
Additionally, their defense is better than I, or anyone else for that matter, expected. 8′9″ 560 lb. nose tackle Albert Haynesworth is at the top of his game, and D-Back Cortland Finnegan is developing into one of the best cornerbacks in the league. With the decline of Champ Bailey, I’m tempted to move him into top-2 area with Antonio Cromartie… But let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
Tennessee still has a long road ahead of them, Indy will only get better, same with Jacksonville, and Houston looks like they’re already done. So, for every star defensive player fighting to win the division, there is a Kerry Collins itching to throw a crippling interception and give it away.
So here we are again… Another late article, another confused, bewildered and exasperated writer.And now… the picks…Cleveland (+3 1/2) at CincinnatiThe worst part about these two awful defenses and laughably inconsistent offenses squaring off on Sunday, is the brewing coaching controversy in Cleveland. Not that Romeo, whom I really like, will be losing his job, but that countless writers and TV analysts will be misusing the word “wherefore” in respect to his impending firing. Not only will newspapers and post game shows be littered with “Wherefore will Romeo go after Cleveland” headlines, and others of the same type, but it’s a given that they will never be corrected either. Some things just get under my skin.
Pick: BengalsHouston (+7) at Jacksonville
It seems Houston has finally found themselves a running back in Steve Slaton that can shoulder a workload needed to take the pressure off Andres Johnson and Davis. Maybe, just maybe that means they’ll become the sleeper team I predicted at the beginning of the season. It could happen. No seriously, it could!
Pick: Jaguars
Minnesota (+3) at Tennessee
Since both of these teams specialize in stopping the run, this game may very well come down to a shootout between Gus Frerotte and Kerry Collins. Until this point, the two of them were most famous for having names that either looked completely wrong every time you typed them out, or looked like a girl’s name. Now, they have a chance to live in glory in what could be the best game of the day. Or, it could be the absolute worst and most boring game ever aired on television. Either way…
Pick: Titans
Denver (-9) at Kansas City
This is the game that for some reason CBS thought Patriots fans should be watching in the Pats’ absence. Yeah, I’m not sure about that. What I am sure of however, is that Larry Johnson finally got going last week after he demanded more carries from Herm Edwards. If Damn Huard (Assuming this is the quarterback the Chiefs have settled on this week, but is subject to change) can manage the game getting the ball to Tony Gonzalez, Dwane Bowe and not fumble on the way to Johnson, they should be able to protect a 5-point-loss at home.
Pick: Chiefs
San Francisco (+5) at New Orleans
Can I use this opportunity to ask a question? San Francisco looks like they’ve finally found a bona fide star at quarterback; someone they can truly model their team around. He has made productive receivers out of guys whose names he may not even know. So, I ask you… Where is Vernon Davis in all of this? All we heard coming out of college is how this guy was the next Antonio Gates, now his fantasy owners couldn’t sell him for a bag of chips to watch the game with. That is so disappointing, that I’m going to select his team anyway.Pick: 49ers
Arizona (+1 1/2) at New York Jets
If New England beat the Jets, and Miami lost to Arizona, and New England lost to Miami, then by the transitive property… No one takes these teams seriously yet anyway…
Pick: Cardinals
Green Bay (+1) at Tampa Bay
When I was just a little guy, about 15 years ago, my father worked at an electrical supply company which did a company-wide pool in which the employees picked five games against the spread. My father always did a couple of sheets, my mother did one, and I did one as well. Even as a 10-year-old boy, I remember my mother’s weekly advice, which she assured me never failed: “Never bet the Bay teams.”
I don’t know why she had this disdain for these teams, besides the fact Tampa Bay was so bad for years previously. In the weeks we were forced to do a “Pick-all,” my mother was driven insane by the problem created by the two teams playing each other. Often times she would simply pick the home team, under protest, and complain about it for the rest of the card.
There is no point to this story, I’m just wasting time because I don’t know who to select. But, seriously, who doesn’t like a story of someone’s mother hating on NFL teams for absolutely no reason.
Pick: Packers
Atlanta (+7) at Carolina
How the Falcons’ fortunes change based on Michael Turner and Matt Ryan:
Game 1 (Win): 220 rush yards, 2 TDs; 161 pass yards, 1 TD, 0 Int 137.0 QB Rat.
Game 2 (Loss): 42 rush yards, 0 TDs; 158 pass yards, 0 TD, 2 Int 29.6 QB Rat.
Game 3 (Win): 103 rush yards, 3 TDs; 192 pass yards, 1 TD, 0 Int 120.6 QB Rat.
If we’re alternating games, it would seem the bad game would be on deck. Since the two wins were against the all-star defenses of Detroit and Kansas City, and since I personally believe Carolina’s defense is getting wildly overrated…
Pick: Falcons
San Diego (-7 1/2) at Oakland
Unbelievably, Al Davis seems to have put together a relatively decent team for 2008 despite his crazy picks in recent years. Actually, no one has survived such an insanely dangerous selection this well since John McCain selected Sarah Palin. Darren McFadden is expected to start, and they’re a home underdog. A Norv Turner team covering 8 points on the road in a hostile environment? Yeah, I’m betting that…
Pick: Raiders
Buffalo (-8) at St. Louis
I really wish someone had come up to me before I wrote my predictions article, and told me that this St. Louis team wouldn’t attempt to stop the run this year, in addition to benching starting quarterback Marc Bulger (Lifetime QB Rating 87.6, lifetime concussions: 0) for Trent Green (Lifetime QB Rating 86.9, lifetime concussions: 87.6), and put him behind an offensive line that couldn’t keep a Jehovah’s Witness out of their own homes, I’m pretty sure I could have resisted the urge to call them division winners. Despite the Rams being a home dog, they’re still on my “Don’t Place Money on This Team Under any Circumstances” list… Jerks.
Pick: Bills
Washington (+11) at Dallas
Just a warning for those of you planning to watch this game in its entirety on television: Prepare for 2 1/2 - 3 hours of ranting and raving about the high quality teams in the NFC East. Included in this endless discussion will include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. How Jason Campbell is developing into a star, and joining the ranks of the best division of quarterbacks in the NFL.
2. How Tony Romo has a plethora of weapons, a stockpile of receiving threats, an overabundance of talent, an excess of pro-bowlers, and an unfair overabundance of fantastically talented receivers, gifted route-running tight-ends, and powerful, versatile running backs that may or may not be the best the Cowboys have had since 1947.
3. How the Super Bowl winner will undoubtedly come from the NFC East, and how it could be either one of these two teams, although it could only actually be the ‘Boys.
4. How Clinton Portis is running “Like a man on a mission,” “With the utmost determination,” “With purpose,” and “Like a bat out of hell.”
Save yourself the John McCain-style repetitive rhetoric, and assume the Cowboys will win by ten in a high scoring affair, and the boys at Guinness may have to be reached at home to check the actual figures for the record number of generic football colloquialisms made over the course of a four quarter game.
Pick: Redskins
Philadelphia (-3) at Chicago
I love Philadelphia this year. DeSean Jackson might be my favorite rookie, and he’s already driven me (and about 2.3 million other people) completely insane with his premature spikeulation in the best game of the season so far. Donovan McNabb is again on his pre-injury roll, Brian Westbrook is Brian Westbrook, and the latest gossip is receiver Hank Baskett has recently bagged former “Girls Next Door” star Kendra Wilkinson. There’s a lot to love about the Eagles, for sure. But home dogs with great defenses? Even more to love there…
Pick: Bears
Baltimore (+5 1/2) at Pittsburgh
Rashard Mendenhall will start for the injured Willie Parker this week, and already sabotaged himself by text messaging Ravens running back Ray Rice, informing him of his intentions to run up his own fantasy scores. Nothing helps your own cause in your debut as an NFL starter like giving the other team bulletin board material and painting a gigantic bull’s eye on the back of your helmet. Way to go, Rashard. On the other hand, it might be a good time to start looking into trades for the guy in your fantasy league. He’s going to start this week, and FastWillie’s got a knee injury, which always heal up in a few days for running backs, right? He may not rock the fantasy world this week, but the kid’s got too much talent not to succeed in Pittsburgh as a starter. Even if it is temporary.
Pick: Steelers
Last Week:
Me: 11-5
LVK: 11-5
Season:
Me: 24-22
LVK: 28-18

