Come along with me as we go through my second fantasy draft this year. This league has 8 teams, with the following roster positions on each team: QB, QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, W/T, W/T, W/R, K, DEF, D, D, D, DB, DB, DL, DL.
The last seven positions are independent defensive players (IDPs). These are a staple of leagues in which I am the commissioner. The other trademark of a Bobby-managed league is PPR, or point-per-reception. These two features add different dynamics to the fantasy leagues, and involves more thinking, research, and preparation. Usually, in my Sigma Tau Gamma league (I was in this fraternity in college, and we still keep up fantasy leagues), there are 12-14 teams. However, baseball is the more popular game, and only the 8 most competitive fantasy managers signed up for this league. That is the reason I added two extra positions at QB and W/T. Another quarterback and another wide receiver would force people to
look deeper into the positions to find their last roster spots, and bench players.
Adding a second quarterback to a league of 8 teams means that on your teams bye week, you have to reach into a crop of players like Aaron Rodgers, Jon Kitna and Jason Campbell as opposed to Matt Hasselbeck, David Garrard and Marc Bulger. As you can see, the talent level drops off considerably at that point. So now you know the set up, let’s get on to the madness…
Round 1
The 1st round went as planned, with no surprises at all. This, of course, was even more foreseeable in an 8 team league. After LDT (You’ll never hear me call Ladainian Tomlinson LT, there already was an LT, and he was the greatest linebacker of all time. More on nicknames much later…), Adrian Peterson, Brian Westbrook, Steven Jackson, Joseph Addai, Randy Moss and Marion Barber flew off the board, I had the opportunity to draft twice in a row. Pick 8 was no question. I queued Tom Brady, happy to get the best QB in the world with the last pick in the first round. Another great aspect of picking last, is you can let your time go down to nothing twice to make one decision. For instance, I knew I was taking Brady, so I had three minutes to choose a running back between Frank Gore, Clinton Portis, Marshawn Lynch, LJ and Ryan Grant. I decided Gore was the safest choice, and reports are that he’s leaner and meaner this year at camp. Besides this, he is probably the best receiving back in this group, and this being a PPR league, that’s kind of important.
Round 2
Those backs all went immediately in the same order listed right after my selection of Gore. This, of course, means I would have been totally screwed had I gone with TO or Reggie Wayne at that spot. Are we learning yet? Regardless of the fact that TO and Wayne may very well score more points than Gore, the ridiculous early run on running backs that happens every year sometimes warrants going for a tailback when a higher-scoring player is available to you. After Grant, Peyton Manning, TO, and Romo rounded out round 2.
Round 3
The guy with the third pick, one of my dearest friends, Craig, selected Reggie Wayne. This was a great move, as he ended up with the best running back, one of the absolute best receivers, and the third-ranked quarterback. This was very smart, despite the fact I wouldn’t allow Tony Romo on my team unless I had no other choice. He lucked out with LDT, then filled the other most important positions with his back-to-back picks. Besides my personal dislike for Tony Romo, he couldn’t have played this much better. I may have to look out for him later. Round 3 continued with Andre Johnson (who I will certainly try to trade for later this
week), Braylon Edwards, MJD, Laurence Maroney, Brandon Jacobs, Willis McGahee, and my crazed outburst of joy when T.J. Houshmandzadeh slipped to me with the last pick of the third round of a PPR league. I queued him instantly and began the tough job of searching for my next guy. Housh falling to me in a PPR league when I had a QB and RB already could only have been divine intervention. This was the fantasy football equivalent of the best looking girl in school asking you to prom because all the guys she wanted to go with had dates already. I know, it never happens, and neither should this! Now, I had to search for the best available player, period. I had a crop of WR’s including Steve Smith, Larry Fitzgerald, Marques Colston, Torry Holt and Wes Welker, with Jamal Lewis, Michael Turner, Reggie Bush, Willie Parker and Darren McFadden. Drew Brees was also tempting here, but I knew I could wait a bit and still grab a high quality quarterback.
.
Round 4
Reggie Bush. Definitely. Three things helped me come to the Bush decision:
- It was down to Wes Welker and him, and as much as I would love to have the co-reception leaders from last year, quality running backs were simply going too fast. It truly hurt me to leave Welker and Colston there, as I had them on my team last year, and they helped me to win the Super Bowl of both my leagues. Yes, we had been through a lot together. And, I swear I could almost hear Wes whimper a little as I placed the cursor over Reggie’s name.
- Antonio Gates is considerably closer to the pack now than he has been in recent years. It was simply too early for a tight end.
- Reggie Bush caught 73 passes last season despite missing the final four games due to injury. Had he had a great last few games, he could have won the reception title as a running back; no easy feat.
After four rounds, I’m sitting pretty with Tom Brady, Frank Gore, T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Reggie Bush, and I couldn’t be happier.
Sure enough, after I voted Reggie, the receiver run began. In what seemed like a matter of seconds, Steve Smith, Larry Fitzgerald, Marques Colston, Torry Holt, Wes Welker and Plaxico Burress went, with Jamal Lewis in the mix somewhere. My next turn would have to result in at least one more receiver if I was going to get a halfway decent one.
Round 5
Luckily, the run slowed a tiny bit with the picks of Drew Brees, Michael Turner, Willie Parker and Darren McFadden, but Brandon Marshall, Chad Johnson (5th round? What has happened to his draft value?), and Anquan Boldin each went too. The only mistakes I saw in this round were Michael Turner and Willie Parker, who I predict will be in fantasy-useless platoons by the fourth exhibition game. Mistakes, but not enough to unleash the vicious insults I was sitting on. I couldn’t wait for someone to really screw up something big. This is what fantasy drafts are all about. I went with Carson Palmer to complete my quarterback tandem. I decided I’d rather have two 30 touchdown QB’s than select two wide receivers back to back here.
Round 6
This is where I encountered an intriguing decision. Just a week or two before this draft, I read an article on Yahoo! sports titled Santonio Holmes vs. Greg Jennings. Interestingly, this was the decision I faced after taking Palmer. Seriously, how often does this happen? I honestly think I like Greg Jennings better, but I went with th
e better quarterback instead. Santonio Holmes had a very good season last year, and very comparable to Jennings. GJ has incredible talent and speed, but will likely have to compete with Donald Driver, James Jones and an assortment of above-average tight ends (two, actually), for catches. Holmes has Hines Ward and Heath Miller, and he’s emerging as the clear favorite for his 32 touchdown-tossing leading man, Ben Roethlisberger. That, to me, pushes him over the top. As an added bonus, everyone in my draft room missed the opportunity to bash me for drafting the one NFL player who recently had naked pictures of him escape to the internet. That could have been embarrassing. This was another case of abandoning one of the key components of my 2007 title run. But, as the Patriots have proved over the better part of the last decade, success sometimes means having to say a cold goodbye. Also, I simply don’t trust Aaron Rodgers yet. Without warning, the tight end rush started. Gates, Jason Witten, Kellen Winslow and Tony Gonzalez all going along with Ben Roethlisberger, Derek Anderson, Earnest Graham, Roy Williams, Roddy White and Marvin Harrison going in rounds 6 & 7 before I chose the last pick of round 7.
Round 7
DeAngelo Williams - Boy do I have man-love for this guy. After his impressive debut in an exhibition game, people suddenly started taking notice nation-wide that maybe Jonathan Stewart can’t walk onto this team and take the starting running back job as a rookie. Maybe the Panthers’ first round pick of two years ago has some talent and deserves a shot to start now that DeShaun Foster is gone. Maybe?
Round 8
With two empty W/T slots remaining and another ex-member of my championship team (Dwayne Bowe) going just before DeAngelo, I had to choose another receiver, and Lee Evans looked very tempting in this spot. He was supposed to explode last year with J.P. Losman, who turned out to be a joke at QB. Maybe with Trent Edwards, the predictions will simply be a year too early. Here’s hoping.
The rest of the round continued with a couple more tight ends, Dallas Clark and Chris Cooley, wideouts Hines Ward, Laveranues Coles and Chris Chambers, along with Thomas Jones and Donovan McNabb. I was absolutely shocked at how intelligently this draft was progressing. I was definitely right about the competitiveness about this 8 person league.
Round 9
This is where most teams grabbed their second quarterback. After Heath Miller went first, Matt Hasselbeck, David Garrard, Marc Bulger and Jay Cutler all went, along with someone named Jerricho and the first white wide receiver to play for the Eagles since Vince Papali. I chose to jump on a tight end here before the run went too far without me, and I scooped up Jeremy Shockey. I’ve never chosen him in any draft in any year before, but I’ve got a good feeling about him this season. He’s in a pass-happy offense with a great quarterback who longs for a big, fat target in goal-line situations. Plus I want him on my team so I can immediately be put on notice when his hillbilly lifestyle conflicting with a city nearly entirely populated by black Americans. I can’t wait!
Round 10
If tight ends hadn’t been selling like hotcakes (whatever that means), I would have gone with the best defensive lineman and defensive back with my consecutive picks, but instead, i was forced to play a hand of one tight end and one Patrick Willis: The #1 name in tackling. I still had a W/T spot open, but I knew I could grab someone valuable down the line that no one would have thought of until they caught a touchdown in week 1. The only problem with this pick, who will definitely bring me more points than any third-rate wide receiver going at this point, is that it caused an avalanche of defensive team picks I simply didn’t see coming. After Willis, round 10 went Minnesota (what?), San Diego, Jake Delhomme, Matt Schaub, D.J. Williams, Donald Driver, New England.
Round 11
Edgerrin James, Chicago, Jon Beason, New York Giants (whoops), Pittsburgh, Eli Manning, Brett Favre. Now that’s a defensive team run. If you’re keeping score (or not), that’s 6 defensive teams in between my 10th and 11th picks of the draft. I had to pick Dallas here, right? I mean they’ve added depth all around, and a future hall of famer at middle linebacker, that’s worth something, right? And a good defense is always aided by a good offense, which you can’t argue against Dallas having. Yes, I am getting defensive, and I don’t care. I was forced into this. At the very least, by choosing a defensive team here, and another defensive player (the best defensive back is still available if you haven’t noticed), I can guarantee that the next couple of rounds will be filled with defensive players, and the best two remaining defensive teams. This means I get to make a good choice at W/T with my next pick. Now I’m manipulating the draft with my consecutive picks. Now I’m having fun.
Round 12
Antonio Cromartie. Yeah, that’ll work. The best defensive back in the game to add to my best tackling linebacker in the game. This’ll throw people into a fit, I’m sure of it. I just stoked the fire of panic in my opponents, and I couldn’t be happier. I started looking at receivers to fill my last spot, when the draft suddenly took an unintentionally hilarious turn for the worse. The following is the exact order of picks in round 12, and I’m not even close to kidding:
- Antonio Cromartie (Thank you, thank you very much…)
- Nick Folk (Whoops…)
- Shayne Graham (Oh man, double whoops…)
- Adam Vinatieri (…)
- Nate Kaeding (What… what is going on?!)
- Ernie Sims (Back on track…)
- Stephen Gostkowski (WHAT THE $*@&!?!?!?)
- Charles Woodson
I was so angry. I had waited 11 rounds to hurl the first insults at the knucklehead who drafted a kicker too early, and it inexplicably happened with five teams at once. There is no excuse, explanation or precedent for such an occurence. Not only were there plenty of IDPs left who would score way, way more points than a kicker, there were plenty of potentially high-scoring receivers and running backs for bench spots or final active roster spots! This bothered me so much, until these five completely useless picks allowed me to steal the guys in 13 & 14.
Round 13
Finally, people started grabbing their defensive players en masse. Asante Samuel, Will Blackmon (This is why you pre-rank players if you don’t plan on showing up for the draft), Bernard Berrian, Jared Allen, Mike Vrabel, Willie Andrews (Take what I just said about showing up and pre-ranking, except this time, shout it out loud when you read it), Travis Williams (This pick is the equivalent of receiving a UPS’ed ziplock bag of dog dung for no reason. Something tells me this guy won’t be happy when he sees I picked DeMeco Ryans after he selected the 5th string linebacker and special teams nobody from the Atlanta Falcons). My DeMeco Ryans pick was immediately followed by…
Round 14
Brian Urlacher. God bless those place-kicking loving idiots of the fantasy universe, they just bought my ticket to the playoffs. Of course, after these picks, they IDP onslaught continued, this time with effective players going off the board such as Jason Taylor, London Fletcher, Terrence McGee, E.J. Henderson, Lofa Tatupu and Ed Reed all went, then the best pick of the draft. And by best, of course, I mean most unintentionally hilarious pick of all time.
Round 15; Pick 4; 116th overall: Adam Jones. Drafted in 2005, suspended since 2006. He has never made more than 51 total tackles or intercepted more than 4 passes. This is seriously the strangest part of the Adam Jones saga. Poeple seem to have him confused wtih a cornerback who actually made a difference in the games he played in. His career stats are reflective of an athletic corner who was occasionally in the right place in the right time. What upsets me so much abou tthis is not that someone took him too early in a fantasy draft, but that a great cornerback nickname was wasted on a painfully average D-back who hasn’t played since Roger Goodell first took over as commissioner.
Wouldn’t Ed Reed be a much better fit for this nickname? Or Rashean “Pacman” Mathis? Terrence “Pacman” McGee? Asante “Pacman” Samuel? Someone who actually gobbled up passes to make the nickname make sense? I can’t possibly be the only one who is upset about this.
Round 15
I ended round 15 with the only offensive player chosen in that round: Chris Henry. I loved this pick because he’s extremely talented, and if he truly has changed his ways, he’ll definitely score a touchdown in every game he’s not suspended for. I’ll spare you the rest of the IDPs chosen, so here is how my final roster ended up looking:
QB - Tom Brady (1)
QB - Carson Palmer (5)
RB - Frank Gore (2)
RB - Reggie Bush (4)
WR - T.J. Houshmandzadeh (3)
WR - Santonio Holmes (6)
TE - Jeremy Shockey (9)
W/T - Lee Evans (8)
W/T - Chris Henry (15)
W/R - DeAngelo Williams (7)
K - Mason Crosby (24)
DEF - Dallas (11)
D - Troy Polamalu (19)
D - Brian Urlacher (14)
D - Will Witherspoon (16)
DL - Patrick Willis (10)
DL - DeMeco Ryans (13)
DB - Antonio Cromartie (12)
DB - Oshiomogho Atogwe (17)
BN - Julius Jones (18), James Jones (20), Joey Galloway (21), Chris Johnson (22), James Hardy (23), Deuce McAllister (25)
A few final thoughts on this draft:
- I feel like I absolutely, positively, grand larceny, 20 years to life stole Julius Jones in this draft. A very talented, 27-year-old running back who is going to shoulder the majority of the workload in Seattle in the 18th round? Yes, please. Behind the strength of a very good offensive line led by Walter Jones, who at 34, could still keep an SUV out of its own driveway, Jones is bound for very goodness this season (I’m tempted to say greatness, but he’ll probably share some time with Maurice Morris before proving he’s far better suited to be a starter). In the 18th round, when other people were taking all IDPs and the top 6 ranked kickers were already gone (read that again… don’t laugh… I dare you to try it… seriously), to get a starting running back on a playoff-bound team in a bad division, I’ll take that, please. Medium-well. No onions.
- Because of simply showing up to the draft and waiting until the second-to-last round to draft a kicker, and having a list of the highest-scoring IDPs in this particular league, I ended up with a defensive team full of absolute studs. Under normal circumstances, there is no reason Patrick Willis, DeMeco Ryans, and Antonio Cromartie should ever end up on the same team. With a healthy Polamalu, Will Witherspoon and Brian Urlacher, it will take an act of God, or a shared bye week oversight by me for me to lose an advantage in defensive points. I’m not tooting my own horn, seriously. Take a look. Would you replace anyone on that defensive roster with anyone? It was as if I drafted mine, then everyone else took what was left. How many times do I have to tell you people to know the league you’re drafting in BEFORE you draft? I can’t wait to reject the first trade offer for Patrick Willis involving someone’s backup tight end and backup defensive team. I really can’t wait.
- A tip to those who haven’t drafted yet - Look at my 8th and 24th round picks. These may be far more important than you know.
- Lee Evans: Was supposed to have a pro-bowl caliber season last year, and disappointed. Very talented, and now with Trent Edwards throwing to him far more often that J.P. Losman ever did (and more accurately), he should come through. However, since I took what I consider a as a risk with this pick, I also picked Chris Henry for an active spot, as well as James Jones, Joey Galloway and James Hardy for bench spots in case Evans doesn’t pan out. The very simple lesson here is to back up your gambles! Don’t draft Aaron Rodgers for your bye week if you have Peyton Manning and Carson Palmer for your QB spots. Worry about that when the bye week actually rolls around. You only have so many bench spots and they could mean the difference between a championship and a bronze medal.
- Mason Crosby: I can’t explain how important it is not to draft a kicker until the second-to-last round. It makes me literally vomit into my mouth when people take one before every position is filled with at least one backup at running back and wide receiver. Kicking is so completely arbitrary that is literally insane to try and get a “good” one. Past “top kickers” have included Robbie Gould and Neil Rackers. Think anyone saw those coming? Your best bet (And this is why I still include kickers - there is a way to draft kicking effectively) is to try and get someone with a strong leg (note: Adam Vinatieri, while very accurate, does not have a strong leg), on a team with no serious, bruising goal line threat. The more they get rejected in goal line situations, the more these red zone drives will result in field goals. My guy Mason has a heck of a leg, one of the best in the league, with a great offense, but Ryan Grant to me is not a “I’m walking right over your defensive line whether you like it or not” kind of guy. He’s great, but Aaron Rodgers as a rookie and Grant as a second-year back will probably result in quite a few field goals, in addition to Crosby’s already great leg.
- Two more things: People are taking the Giants’ defense too early, and Tom Brady too late. Tom Brady is the best quarterback in the world, and he’s got a great offensive line in front of him. The only receiver he lost was Donte Stallworth, and he didn’t throw to him much anway. He still has the best receiver in the game in Moss, the Million-catch Man in Wes Welker, and Chad Jackson, who most people don’t know, but was the second-best receiving prospect in the 2006 draft after Santonio Holmes. Hopefully with a chance this season, he will break out as well. As for New York’s defense: They lose more than half of their team! And, oh, yeah… Osi Umenyiora is now out for the year. So, we can go ahead and stop drafting them amongst the top defenses in the game, right? Right. Thanks, Bobby. You’re welcome.
Well, it’s been fun everyone. I hope you learned a lot, and had some fun. I certainly did, and I’m psyched to find out who I’m going to play in this year’s Super Bowl. Happy Drafting!