Surprisingly enough, I’ve received just enough supportive, insulting, poignant and offensive emails to make a mailbag entry. Thanks to everyone that contributed. Without further ado, away we go…
You obviously know the same amount about basketball as you do about fantasy baseball. Not only are the Lakers going to win this series, but the Celtics won’t win a game. Listen to the experts, great offense always beats great defense (and the Celtics D isn’t that great). Lakers will sweep, and KG will be known as the greatest choke artist in the history of the playoffs!
-Kyle G., Minneapolis
I thought this email was funny for so many reasons. First, obviously it was written before games 1 and 2 of the Finals, which made me laugh. The Celtics won the first two games of the series with rebouding, energy, matchups and a superior bench (Someone mentioned these beforehand, can’t remember who…). Also, this emailer used his second overall pick, and subsequent 2nd rounder in the mid-season league to select Milton Bradley and Cliff Lee. There’s no joke here.
And, lastly, the most irrational Laker fan I heard from happens to live in the city the team abandoned years ago. There seems to be abandonment issues here that I simply don’t have time to touch upon. Oh yeah, and his initials are KG.
Needless to say, these Finals are unfolding beautifully if you’re a Bostonian. With the exception of Make-Up Call Extravaganza ‘08 (Game 3), the Celts have shown extended periods of dominance where the Lakers have looked confused and helpless. Even if the Lakers figure themselves out, it will take the entire trio of KG, PP and RA alternating terrible performances, or horrendous officiating to turn this series completely around.
I thought I was crazy during game 1. Then during game 2, I couldn’t shake the feeling again. Could it possible be that Doc Rivers is out-coaching Phil Jackson?
-Steve, South Boston
Phil Jackson has two major things going against his attempt to coach this series well. First, his virus of a star player. This is the most harrowing obstacle he faces and I honestly couldn’t begin to attempt advice here. For every complex scheme, impromptu play, well-timed timeout and sagely piece of wisdom he hands out, Kobe shoots someone an evil glare, yells at a teammate, tries to coach the team himself or simply plays the way he wants to. Apparently by passing up shots to give teammates looks in the first half, he thinks he can create the illusion he’s unselfish and a great guy. As a Celtic fan, any time he’s not taking advantage of the one-on-ones the Celtics have thrown at him with Ray Allen, I’ll take it.
Secondly, Doc has nothing to lose here, reputation-wise. He’s the decisive underdog in terms of his team and his coaching ability. Historically, everything Phil Jackson touches turns to gold, and Doc is a media darling ex-player who has been stuck coaching a horrible team for a while. Who wouldn’t want that kind of cushion to fall on in case of a failure? “Well, at least it was to Phil Jackson and the best team in the western conference. I’m just Doc Rivers, it’s my first time here!” For PJ, the stakes are slightly raised. We’re talking beginner’s luck compared to Hall of Fame legacy. Until the Celtics win the series due to something related directly to Jackson’s coaching, I’m going to have to say no.
You wrote that Miguel Cabrera, David Wright, Josh Beckett and Johan Santana would be taking home the major awards this season. Want to rethink those now? Cliff Lee could wrap up the Cy Young by the 4th of July!
-Rich, Cleveland, OH
While I may have missed on my AL predictions (due to injury and an adjustment period I absolutely should have seen coming), I stand by my NL fortune telling. Johan hasn’t even gotten hot yet and is one of the top pitchers in the National League. Also, Wright survived his notoriously bad May performance with decent numbers, and is sure to light up opposing pitchers for the remainder of the year. Although admittedly it will take quite a performance to take Chase Utley out of the NL MVP driver’s seat.
Although I wrote Cabrera’s name for MVP in the predictions column, I don’t think I actually believed myself. There is definitely an adjustment period for players coming from the national league (AAA compared to AL pitching). Also, Beckett seems to be pitching without that murderous look in his eyes after his injury early in the season. While both of these players will be okay down the stretch, neither is looking at an award right now. For the MVP, it’s going to be a tough challenge to overtake Josh Hamilton and his 3,248 RBI pace. As for the Cy Young award, Cliff Lee certainly is having a great bounceback year, but he’s starting to come back down to Earth already. I actually will look to C.C. Sabathia (Yes, I realize he has eight losses), fresh off a complete game shutout, to absolutely dominate down the stretch of his contract year. If you need a pitcher in any fantasy league, now is the time to make a play for the big guy.
Does anyone know Kevin Garnett’s phone number? Someone needs to tell him to stay near the basket when that hook-shooting glacier is trying to guard him. Since Doc won’t do it, I figure I’d give him a call.
-Paul, Amherst
I’m not sure if Kevin Garnett is married or what his situation is, but someone needs to set up the situation from “Dodgeball” where Gordon’s mail-order bride is being romanced by David Hasselhoff in the stands during an important match. He immediately becomes furious and aggressive, and a better player. This NEEDS to happen with KG, or else I’m not sure he can become the player he needs to be in the playoffs.
Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate everything the Big Ticket has brought to the table this season, but I can’t remember any situation in the history of sports where one player seems to be holding so much of his talent back for no reason at all. So, Paul, no I don’t have his number. But, if you can’t come up with it, I’d also try David Hasselhoff and see what he’s doing tomorrow night…
Who is Boston has access to the memory eraser from “Men in Black?” I want to know who is responsible for making Lamar Odom forget how to play basketball.
-Kyle, L.A.
The man you’re looking for is Tom Thibodeau. His defensive schemes seem to have taken Odom completely out of his game. Although, badly bricking free throws and creating stupid penalties for himself were a consistent part of his game until recently, so maybe someone just reminded him how to play his old game.
Andy Pettitte is 5-5 with 55 strikeouts and an ERA of 5. Could he be headed for the most average season of all time? Is that even a legitimate superlative?
-Keith, NJ
What an unbelievable chain of events. He and Clemens are both named in the Mitchell report, Pettitte admits limited usage, apologizes, and that was that. Clemens vehemently denies steroids, appears in front of a panel of congressmen, looks like a complete fool, invents the word “misremember,” and while heading toward perjury charges, gets embroiled in a scandal involving an extramarital affair with at least one woman, with unsubstantiated reports of more. I have absolutely no idea why athletes even try denying use anymore. Even if one were completely innocent, it almost seems easier to admit using, apologize, and vow to be an advocate for fair play from then on. Just look at the list of admitted users who apologized, compared to people who denied usage, but were branded guilty by the public anyway:
Admitted: Andy Pettitte, Rodney Harrison, Shawne Merriman, Brian Roberts, Rick Ankiel
Denied: Mark McGwire, Rafael Palmeiro, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Gary Sheffield, Jason Giambi (I’m including him here because his half-ass apology may have been more of an insult than a flat-out denial would have been)
In every case, the first list members are accepted back and loved by their fans, with the second list’s members being written off as cheaters and liars. Amazing. It may be easier to lie about taking performance enhancing drugs if you didn’t do them than to clear your name if you’re truly innocent. I’d blame the society we live in if baseball didn’t absolutely bring this on itself to begin with.
Great site! You have some great points in your posts, and it’s very funny. However, you’re wrong about the Celtics winning this series… Everyone forgets the West is still the superior conference! The East hasn’t caught up that fast, Lakers will win in 7.
-DJ, San Diego
Can’t disagree with much about this email, except that the Celtics and Pistons have most definitely caught up. Maybe teams 3-8 in the playoffs weren’t in the same league as 3-8 in the West, but I would take the Pistons (when motivated) over almost all the Western playoff teams as well.
As a side note, for all those Laker fans out there thinking that Paul Pierce is a faker, drama queen, crybaby or whatever other name one would like to throw out there, read Bill Simmons’s article on ESPN.com from today. He has a great couple of paragraphs discussing Pierce’s comeback performances after being repeatedly stabbed and having his front teeth broken on separate occasions. When the guy says he’s hurt, he’s hurt. He’s done as much as any basketball player could possible do to earn the benefit of the doubt. That goes for you, too, Phil Jackson.
Thanks for writing in everyone, and emails are always welcome. Please send questions, comments or anything else to bobby@sportsomedy.com. Please include your name and location with the email.